Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Mike McCutchan
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Mike McCutchan

4313 E Morgan Avenue Suite B
Evansville, IN 47715-2267

Located across from Showplace Cinema, next to Howard Golf store.

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


4313 E Morgan Avenue Suite B
Evansville, IN 47715-2267



Hi, welcome to the Mike McCutchan State Farm Insurance Agency in Evansville IN!

We serve the entire state of Indiana with a focus on relocations and out of State Transfers to Warrick and Vanderburgh Counties. Locally, we serve the towns of Evansville, Newburgh, Boonville, Princeton, Mt Vernon and the surrounding IN areas! I have been a State Farm insurance Agent since 2021 and offer Car/Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Renters Insurance, Condo Insurance, Life Insurance, Business/Commercial Insurance and so much more!

I became a State Farm Agent to make a difference in the way people purchase insurance products which are designed to protect what matters most. With over 10 years of combined insurance experience my team of top-notch industry leaders can educate you on your options while being respectful to your budget and decisions. Over the years my office qualified for several awards including State Farm’s Ambassador Travel & State Farm Honor Club.

I’m a lifelong Evansville native and graduate of IUPUI with a degree in Business Management from the Kelly School of Business. I'm a proud husband to Melissa and dad to my daughters Trae and Reese. I am also a stepdad to Noah, and Jaxson, and Levi, who are twins. When I'm not in the office I enjoy watching all the sports that the kids play (which at the moment can be all over the country), trying new places to eat, traveling, and playing with our 3 mini doodles Bella, Teddy, and Jake!! Yep, we even named the newest puppy "Jake, from State Farm!"

No matter what your situation is, my team and I have one simple goal in mind: to protect your family through all walks of life, with the personable service of any small town business. Whether buying your first car, moving into your dream home or planning for your retirement- my hard working State Farm team and I commit to bringing you the highest degree of quality customer care. We will listen and work diligently to implement an insurance and financial services plan to help you protect what matters most. Give us a call or stop by the office today for a free insurance quote, we can’t wait to meet you!

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Annuities

How to buy a car online

It's becoming more common to buy a car online. We'll offer helpful advice for car buyers for purchasing and leasing to ensure a safe and satisfactory transaction.

Safety products for your home

Look for these basic safety products for your new home. Safety supplies like these can help keep you and your family safe.

The Real Consequences of Drunk Driving

What's at stake if you're caught drunk driving? A lot. These tips help you avoid the dangers of drinking and driving.

View More Articles

Our mission is to become your first choice for all of your insurance needs by establishing a personal relationship & helping you understand the risks you face every day. We focus on Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Renters Insurance, Life Insurance, and Business Insurance throughout the Evansville IN, area including Newburgh, Boonville, Princeton, Mt Vernon, Warrick and Vanderburgh County. When the unfortunate incidents occur we pledge to be there to assist you through the good & bad.

Our team is on standby and ready to serve your needs. Please give us a call to review your coverage options, make policy changes, start or check in on a claim or make a payment. We'd love to meet you in person. Drop by the office or schedule an appointment today!

Morgan Maurer State Farm Agent Team Member

Morgan Maurer

Office Manager

My name Is Morgan, I was born and raised in Evansville, IN. I started my career with the Mike McCutchan Agency on his opening day with State Farm in October 2021. As office manager I can assist you with all lines of insurance including life, health, home, auto and more. When I am not assisting customers in the office you can find me hanging out with family or at my childrens sporting events.

Baylee Pate State Farm Agent Team Member

Baylee Pate

Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep

My name is Baylee Pate, I grew up in Posey County but now reside in Evansville. I am a mom to 3 busy kiddos and have one more on the way. The mother in me loves taking care of people. I have been with Mike McCutchan State Farm for almost 2 years now. I focus most of my time helping customers with their life insurance, while also assisting with auto, home and renters insurance. The highlight of my career is helping families protect what matters most.

Ashley Davenport State Farm Agent Team Member

Ashley Davenport

Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep

Hi! I am Ashley Davenport. A little bit about me, I moved from Southern Illinois to Warrick County in June 2021 with my family. I was a stay at home mom for 3 years and finally decided it was time to get back to work in 2023. That was when I started to work for Mike McCutchan State Farm and enjoyed helping all our customers with all their Auto, Home, Life and Health Insurance needs. I am very personable and will listen to what your needs are and make sure that we get you great coverages!


Justin Connaughton

Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep


Bailey Jimenez

Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep